Book excerpts Acarya Kesari Discussion Regarding Touched and Untouched bhoga in Sri Jagannatha Mandira

Discussion Regarding Touched and Untouched bhoga in Sri Jagannatha Mandira

On 3 November 1963, an article was published in the Bengali daily newspaper Yuganantara regarding bhoga worth thousands of rupees being thrown away in Puri. “Today, 1 November, a person who was not engaged in deity service touched the bhoga by sight before it was offered to Sri Jagannathaji in the evening. This resulted in an uprising among the cooks, and the police had to intervene. In accordance with temple procedure, thousands of rupees worth of bhoga was disposed of and buried in the ground.” (VNI 1.11.1963)

Paramaradhyatama Srila Gurudeva commented on this incident as follows: “We are attracting the attention of the public by this incident, which Sri Jagannatha-deva Himself has arranged. Some people try to disregard the offence of touch in bhagavat-seva, and want to dismiss as insignificant the distinction between ‘touched’ and ‘untouched’. Such people are hypocrites and are opposed to the path of dharma. We should accept this teaching of Sri Jagannatha-deva and always remain on the path of distinguishing between ‘touched’ and ‘untouched’ bhoga, according to scriptural rules. We should also instruct others to stay on this path. This deceitful concept is atheistic, and we should never let it enter into the worship of Bhagavan, whether it comes from Western atheists or native atheists. Even today the conception of food as lawful or unlawful is observed in Sri Jagannatha temple and exists in different systems all over India. We consider those who do not acknowledge the offence of touch (sparsa-dosa) to be untouchables.

“It is not an offence to touch the preparation after it has been offered to Sri Jagannatha-deva, for the bhoga prepared by the cooks then becomes maha-prasada. But no one has the right to touch the bhoga before it is offered, apart from Sri Jagannatha-deva’s servants who are qualified to prepare and offer it. No offering (naivedya) that has been touched by an unqualified person can ever be offered to Sri Jagannathaji. This is the correct understanding.

“Human beings should only accept Sri Bhagavan’s remnants, and it is improper to give anyone anything that Sri Jagannathaji has not accepted. Sri Jagannathaji is using this incident to teach us that Bhagavan does not want to accept any unofferable substances. There is another instruction within this one. Meat, fish, eggs, tobacco, tea, bidis, cigarettes, chewing tobacco, alcohol, coffee, onion, garlic and so on cannot be included in an offering to Bhagavan. Therefore, all these substances are to be rejected. Those who make use of these unlawful substances in service to the deity belong to non-bona fide sampradayas and have no connection with Hindu sanatana-dharma. The sastras call such people outcastes (mlecchas) or those born in the lowest caste (antyaja).”

The servants of Sri Jagannatha-deva, along with virtuous men following Hindu dharma, were very pleased with Srila Gurudeva’s argument.

Preaching in Siligudi and Bihara

After Sri Dhama Navadvipa parikrama and Sri Gaura-janmotsava in 1963, paramaradhya Srila Gurudeva went preaching for a week with his associates to various places in the Sundaravana region, including Maipitha-Vinodapura, Damakala and Kasinagara. From there, he went all around Siligudi and preached sanatana-dharma (suddha-bhakti) extensively for almost a month, from 21 April to 18 May.

During the same period in the following year, 1964, he preached vaisnava-dharma with sannyasis and sixteen matha residents in Sarasajola, Asanavani, Rajavandha, Palasi, Baramasiya, Dhadika, Kumadavada, Dumaka town and other places in the Dumaka district of Bihara. Accompanying Srila Gurudeva at that time were Sripada Trivikrama Maharaja, Sripada Narayana Maharaja [the author], Sripada Krsna-krpa Brahmacari, Sri Gajendra-moksana Brahmacari, Sri Rohini-nandana Vrajavasi, Sri Bhagavan dasa Brahmacari, Sri Vrndavana-vihari Brahmacari, Sri Cidghananada Brahmacari, Sri Vrsabhanu Brahmacari and other leading sannyasis and brahmacaris.

Sarasajola is a well-known and prosperous village in the Dumaka district. Srila Gurudeva stayed in Sri Madhusudana Vidyanidhi’s home in Sarasajola and preached suddha-bhakti there for seven days. All the leading villagers there accepted vaisnava-dharma along with their families. Sarasajola became like Kulina-grama, whose inhabitants were all great Vaisnava devotees during Sriman Mahaprabhu’s time. In those days, there were only Vaisnavas in the village of Kulina-grama; even the village dogs were devotees who observed Ekadasi and other vratas. Similarly, Sarasajola became blessed by Srila Gurupada-padma’s auspicious arrival there. He lectured for six days there on the following six different subjects:

  1. What is sastra?
  2. The distinction between demigods (suras) and demons (asuras).
  3. Kirtana is the only beneficial sadhana.
  4. To merge with brahma, or to become brahma, is a curse for the jiva.
  5. Isvara is savisesa (with a personal feature) and sakara (with form), not nirakara (formless).
  6. Nirakara-vada (the doctrine stating that God is formless) is only an atheistic heretical concept (pakhanda-vada).

Among the other speakers were Sripada Trivikrama Maharaja, Sripada Narayana Maharaja [the author], Sri Cidghananada Brahmacari and Sri Rohini-nandana Vrajavasi.

Srila Acaryadeva gave brilliant discourses in Dumaka town for three days at the Popular Club, Sri Radha-Madhava temple and the District Council House. Srila Gurudeva lectured on subjects such as ‘Sad-darsana and vedanta-vijnana’, ‘The worthlessness of nirakaravada’ and ‘Dharma-seva is the only perfection of society’. At his request, Sripada Trivikrama Maharaja and Sripada Narayana Maharaja lectured on sri gaura-lila and sri rama-lila. They illustrated these talks, full of bhakti-siddhanta, with slide shows. The preaching of suddha-bhakti in these parts of the Dumka district inspired the people to have unsurpassed faith in vaisnava-dharma. Whole groups of them gave up alcohol, meat, fish, smoking and so on, and were initiated into suddha-bhakti. Srila Acaryadeva and his associates returned to Sri Devananda Gaudiya Matha after preaching in this way for about a month.

In August 1964, Srila Gurudeva was at Sri Devananda Gaudiya Matha during the grand and festive celebration of Sri Sri Janmastami and Sri Nandotsava. Many educational exhibitions were organized on the matha’s premises, and the devotees eagerly requested Srila Gurupada-padma to open the exhibition. In the religious assembly in the natya-mandira, he delivered a lecture on Sri Janmastami which was filled with profound siddhanta.

Srila Acaryadeva said that it is a mistake to observe Sri Janmastami and fasting for other vratas in accordance with the views of the smarta Raghunandana. According to Hari-bhakti-vilasa, when Vaisnavas observe these vratas, they should abandon mixed tithis and observe suddha-vrata. Sri Krsna did not take birth on saptami-biddha-astami (Astami mixed with Saptami), but rather on navami-biddha-astami (which is also called Uma-Mahesvari tithi).

Navami combined with Astami tithi is therefore the tithi to be observed for the vrata. Abhijita-muhurta (the eighth muhurta of the day, a very powerful muhurta at about midday), the Rohini constellation and other considerations are also of special importance for this vrata.

[CC-by-ND GVP]

Must Read

Is God Partial? – Srimad Bhagavatam

God is sama-darsi, He is equal to all. But that means that according to one’s actions, a corresponding result occurs. We should not think that we can do anything we like, any sinful activity, and no result will come to us. If we do sinful or evil actions, and cause suffering to others, then we will suffer in return...

Greed is the Only Price – 23 May 1996, England

Remembering these pastimes, the Gosvamis sometimes laugh. Feeling intense pangs of separation, they bitterly weep and roll on the earth. They then think, “Oh Krsna is going to enter the groves.” They become so happy again. So, we don’t think that, “All the Vaisnavas are in my category.” We don’t try to drag them into our category. It will be an offense...


I brought you here to touch this place, and to touch the feet of these trees. These trees are exalted devotees. They previously saw the Lord's pastimes as trees, and now they are performing austerities in this form. One day they will have gopi forms, and at that time they will be able to enter rasa-lila and other such pastimes. This scenery is so beautiful. If anyone has a camera he should take a picture of it...


People are afraid of sādhus because of this. The sādhus cut away our five types of sufferings:  (i) avidyā, ignorance or forgetfulness of Kṛṣṇa;  (ii) asmitā, or the false egoism arising from the conceptions of “I” and “mine”; (iii) rāga, or attachment for the objects of sense gratification; (iv) dveṣa, or hatred or aversion to unpleasant, disagreeable or adverse situations; and (v) abhiniveṣa, or attachment for or absorption in sinful activities.They vanquish our material attractions, desires, and attachments. By their power, they will remove all our kleśa. This process seems painful, but this is a stage of our purification and is necessary. Still people think, “Oh, I can come to the dhāma, but who will take care of me when I am old? I will suffer so much and I will not have any one to support me.” But we should have faith in God and His devotees. If we surrender to them, they will make all arrangements for our welfare.The sādhus who are completely free from mundane attachments wield the medicine that cures our material disease. You might think, “When I sit in front of sādhus, they are so strong that it feels like they are cutting me and then throwing salt on my wounds. They are tormenting me.”But this is the process of our purification. Once we are freed of our sickness, we will feel so much happiness. We have been suffering for so many millions of lifetimes from this material disease. Once we are cured we will feel so much bliss. Therefore, we should not be afraid of taking the treatment of sādhus. Sādhus purify everyone by the nectar of hari-kathā. We can receive this rasa by going to sādhu-saṅga.The stage of kleśaghnī—when we undergo the somewhat painful identification and subsequent eradication of our kleśa, or misery—has been described. The next stage is śubhadā. At this stage we do not suffer; rather, people respect us. They give us wealth and opulence, and offer us worship. This is an extremely dangerous stage. If, at this time, we forget guru and Vaiṣṇavas, then again we will fall into māyā’s clutches. We must be very steady in our sādhana at the stage of śubhadā.Rūpa Gosvāmī writes:yad-brahma-sākṣāt-kṛti-niṣṭhayāpi,vināśam āyāti vinā na bhogaiḥapaiti nāma! sphuraṇena tat te,prārabdha-karmeti virauti vedaḥKṛṣṇa-nāmāṣṭakam 4O nāma! The Vedas loudly declare that even without a devotee undergoing any suffering, his prārabdha-karma, which cannot be eliminated even by resolute meditation on impersonal brāhmaṇa, is at once mitigated by Your appearance on the tongue.Everyone must suffer the results of their prārabdha and aprārabdha-karma, but if we are always doing nāma-kīrtana, then those reactions are taken away from us by those who are criticizing us or abusing us. This is the only way that the tasting of those fruits is avoided. Those who respect us and praise us take away our puṇya, or the fruits of piousness. Bhajana cannot be performed so long as pāpa and puṇya are present. (click on the Title to read full article)


“An old Bābājī Mahārāja once lived in a village called Raṇavāḍī in Vraja-maṇḍala more than a hundred years ago. At one point, the desire awakened in him to have darśana of Dvārakā. A brāhmaṇa family came who were going to Dvārakā and offered to take the Bābājī along, paying the full cost of travel. The Bābājī agreed and they took him along with them.

More Articles Like This