Book excerpts Acarya Kesari Preaching Sanatana-dharma in Vasirahata and the Reply to Sri Chattopadhyaya Mahasaya’s Protest

Preaching Sanatana-dharma in Vasirahata and the Reply to Sri Chattopadhyaya Mahasaya’s Protest

Throughout 1950, Srila Guru Maharaja extensively preached sri sanatana-dharma in Medinipura, Naraghata, Sitalapura, Haldiya, Tamaluk, Bajipura in Chaubisa Paragana, Vasirhata and other places. In the large religious assembly of Vasirhata, Acarya Kesari established with a lion-like voice the philosophical conclusions of sanatana-dharma and refuted the worthless, non-Vedic kevaladvaita-vada put forward by the hidden Buddhist, Acarya Sankara, as well as the modern conclusions opposed to the Veda.

Sri Gurudeva said that bhagavad-bhakti, devotion to the Supreme Lord, is sanatana-dharma. The constitutional position of the jiva is to be a servant of Bhagavan. Therefore, service of Bhagavan is sanatana-dharma in the past, present and future. It is also known as Vedic dharma, bhagavata-dharma and vaisnava-dharma. The jiva and the material world are never false. The jiva is eternally a part of Bhagavan, and the material world, which is manifested by Bhagavan’s inferior potency (apara-prakrti), is also true although changeable and perishable. The world is not false or illusory like a dream, or like a rope resembling a snake. The ideas of Sankara, which are illusory and contrary to logic, are only respected by extremely dull-witted people. [Sri Gurudeva concluded his talk by saying,] “This is what we are teaching the young men of the Vedanta Samiti.”

In Sri Gaudiya-patrika’s fourth issue, during its second year of publication, a synopsis of the above lecture given by Srila Guru Maharaja was published. After reading the article, Sri Satyabhusana Chattopadhyaya Mahodaya of Tatanagara wrote a letter of protest. Srila Guru Maharaja replied to his letter using scriptural logic and siddhanta. Srila Guru Maharaja’s letter is cited below.

“To summon the well-educated community of the world to attain real realization of the Absolute (tattva-darsana) is not to challenge anyone in any way. Careful consideration and comparison has established that the Gaudiya Vaisnavas’ philosophy of simultaneous oneness and difference (acintya-bhedabheda-siddhanta) is superior to Acarya Sankara’s advaita-vada or mayavada (impersonalism). Pure Vaisnavas do not have even the slightest trace of faith in Acarya Sri Sankara’s views, although we see that some proud, mixed Vaisnavas have faith in mayavada. We are Vaisnava sannyasis, and we consider the refinement of society to be part of the purification process of dharma. It is our right to present the truth of any subject to the educated community for their welfare. Some people may become disturbed when we preach truth, because they accept non-truth as the truth; but we do not want to agitate anyone. We only want to say that Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu’s teachings and practice are the foremost in the entire world. We do not blaspheme Acarya Sankara, but we are not about to praise his opinions and doctrines in any way.” Srila Gurudeva’s answers to Sri Chattopadhyaya Mahasaya’s many questions about mayavada were published in instalments in Sri Gaudiya-patrika.
Sri Navadvipa-dhama parikrama, Sri Gaura-janmotsava and the deities’ entrance into their new residence.

In March 1951, the week-long Sri Navadvipa-dhama parikrama and Sri Gaura-janmotsava were performed with great pomp. Faithful pilgrims came, not only from Bengal but from all over India. Thanks to Srila Guru Maharaja’s excellent management, all the pilgrims engaged in harinama-sankirtana, listened to hari-katha, took darsana of the places of Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu’s pastimes, and had the good fortune to perform parikrama.

Until that time Sri Devananda Gaudiya Matha, which is Sri Gaudiya Vedanta Samiti’s original matha, was located in a small rented building. This served as a temple where the deities were worshipped and also as headquarters for the management of the entire Sri Navadvipa-dhama parikrama. The pilgrims would stay in tents erected in a nearby field. That year the Samiti enclosed the extensive area where the arrangements for the parikrama were made with a huge fence. A temple for the deities, quarters for the sevakas and a storage place for bhoga were constructed. In another part of the field, tents were set up for lodging the many pilgrims. Before the parikrama, the deities were brought in a grand procession accompanied by sankirtana to their new temple.

The elevated devotee Sriyuta Haripada dasa Adhikari of Sri Ramapura in the Hoogly district and his devout wife, Srimati Jnanada-sundari-devi, generously financed the construction of the high fences and the temple in the huge field. For their contribution, Srila Guru Maharaja showered them with profuse blessings. Their ideal service is an inspiration for other virtuous people.

[CC-by-ND GVP]

Must Read

How Deep is the Mountain?

...Only one who is equal to his self-realized Guru can understand how deep he is. A kanistha-adhikari, neophyte, and a madhyama-adhikari, middle class devotee, cannot guess how deep are his feelings – what are the fathomless moods of krsna-prema and radha-prema in his heart. Without being an uttama-adhikari, a topmost pure devotee, one cannot understand...


Immersed in the mood of the gopīs, Śrīla Gurudeva then bathed Girirāja and offered him āratī with the tears of his eyes. And then, while the devotees danced and sang the glories of Girirāja, Gurudeva bathed him with yogurt, milk, honey, ghee, sugar, and water. The party then continued on parikramā of Girirāja, passing Ānyora Gāoñ, where Kṛṣṇa brought the Vrajavāsīs to worship Girirāja instead of Indra. Here, upon receiving the thousands of preparations prepared by the residents of Vraja, Girirāja assumed a colossal form and, with four arms, devoured all the offerings. He then called out, ‘Āno re! Āno re! (Bring more! Bring more!)’ Kṛṣṇa satisfied Girirāja by giving him a Tulasī leaf. The village Ānyora Gāoñ is thus named, for it is the place where Girirāja manifested and accepted offerings. After Ānyora Gāoñ, the Parikramā proceeded to Govinda-kuṇḍa, named thus from the time that Indra begged Kṛṣṇa’s forgiveness for his offense, bathed Kṛṣṇa with the milk of Mother Surabhī, and named Him “Govinda.” Govinda-kuṇḍa is famous as the place where Kṛṣṇa, in the guise of the cowherd boys, married all the gopīs during the year when Brahmā kidnapped the boys and calves and kept them hidden in a cave. When observed thousands of wedding ceremonies going on at Govinda-kuṇḍa, She perceived that all the boys marrying gopīs were actually Kṛṣṇa. In a fit of jealousy, She hid in a nearby kuñja. After taking ācamana at Govinda-kuṇḍa and hearing hari-kathā, Kṛṣṇa came to pacify Her and laid His crown at Her feet, from which this place came to be known as Mukut-silā. Further along, on the left side of the parikramā path, comes the beautiful Śauri-kuṇḍa, where, after Kṛṣṇa placated Śrimatī Rādhikā, the Divine Couple bathed. From there, the Parikramā came to Pūñarī. Pūñarī marks the southern border of Govardhana and is thus named because it is like the tail, pūñch, of Girirāja, who is likened to a cow with her neck turned into her stomach. At Pūñarī, the party completes parikramā of Govardhana’s eastern side and begins parikramā of the western side. The pilgrims then proceeded to Navala-kuṇḍa and Apsarā-kuṇḍa, adjacent ponds where Kṛṣṇa and the gopīs bathed and assumed the appearance of gāndharvas of heaven before performing the springtime Rāsa, on the western side of Girirāja. Upon crossing the rāsa-sthalī, the Parikramā took darśana of the cave of Rāghava Paṇḍa and then went to Surabhī-kuṇḍa and Airāvata Kuṇḍa, where mother Surabhī and Indra’s elephant carrier, Airāvata, respectively bathed Śrī Kṛṣṇa with milk and water from the Gaṅgā. The party then came to Jatīpurā, where Śrī Mādhavendra Purī found Śrī Nāthajī. When Madhavendra Purī came to Govardhana, he was offered milk by a cowherd boy and, after drinking it, he had a dream of the same boy, who revealed Himself as the Deity Gopāla. This Deity had been concealed in the depths of the jungle by His priests when there was a threat from invaders. Upon waking, Madhavendra Purī searched for Gopāla with the Vrajavāsīs and, after eventually finding Him, arranged for a mahā-abhiṣeka. He then arranged for the first masse observance of Annakūṭa since the time of Kṛṣṇa. This Annakūṭa was repeated every day for over a month, each time sponsored by different wealthy families from Mathurā and Vraja. Jati means a sannyāsī and Jatīpurā is thus named in reference to Madhavendra Purī.


Krṣṇa will not appear in an impure heart. Even materialists will not stay in a dirty area. Cleaning is necessary. Mahāprabhu gave a good chance for cleaning the heart on the day of Guṇḍīcā-mārjana...

The Garden of Vrnda-devi

You don’t understand how much wealth is in Vraja-dhama. You don’t need to carry and take that wealth with you. It will always be with you. Vraja-bhakti and Vraja-rasa will always be present with you. You may not be able to believe this, but the power of this rasa is so great that it will make you forget maya and everything— you will forget where you were from, who you are, or where you are going...

Prabhuji Making a Japa-Mala Video

Haribol! In this video, after cooking lunch for the hundreds of guests who come for the daily free lunch prasada, Prabhuji finishes up making japa-malas for devotees. Radhe Shyam!

More Articles Like This